main

French gov't agency sues Chi Mei over LCD patents

configure   on 31 December 2003 - 02:43 · 23 comments & 2563 views

Advertisement (Why?)
French government agency for atomic energy has filed a patent lawsuit over flat-screen displays against Chi Mei Optoelectronics Corp. , Taiwan's second-largest maker of computer display screens, according to court documents made public Tuesday.

The Commissariat a l'Energie Atomique alleges that Chi Mei infringed on two patents for technology involved in the design and manufacture of liquid crystal modules, a type of flat-screen display used in computer monitors and televisions.

In its complaint, filed in federal court in San Jose last week and transferred to San Francisco Tuesday, the agency seeks an order restraining Chi Mei from exporting to the United States LCDs and LCD products that would infringe on its patents.

A representative for Chi Mei could not be immediately reached. A lawyer for the French government agency in San Francisco declined to comment. Chi Mei told investors last month that surging demand for flat-screen televisions should continue to boost its sales next year, and it expected to capture a 20 percent global market share for television panels.

To meet rising demand for LCDs, the company has plans to build three new plants in Taiwan over the next five years. Chi Mei counts No. 1 personal computer maker Dell Inc. and computer and printer maker Hewlett-Packard Co. as clients.

News source: Forbes - French gov't agency sues Chi Mei over LCD patents


When additional changes were passed by Congress last Thanksgiving, only a few scattered outlets - like Wired News and oddly - Adult Video News - paying attention. While the original Patriot act allows the FBI to request data from your ISP with no court order or judicial oversight, these new changes, tucked away in the Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2004, broaden those powers further. The provisions expand the definition of "financial institution" and "financial transaction", allowing the FBI to monitor everything from Pawn Shops to your ISP with more authority.

Opponents claim that the already weakened system of checks and balances is being eroded futher, and the Fourth Amendment (protection against unreasonable searches and seizures) faces a serious threat. Supporters claim the changes are necessary to track the money funding terrorist operations and prevent further attacks. In between these two groups are usually those who don't care either way, since they're "not doing anything wrong".

The debate between these groups was overshadowed (intentionally or otherwise) by three days of Saddam capture video and elaborate (and fully 3D) explorations of the hole Iraq's one-time leader crawled out of. As usual with American media, all other news is often buried during major events - something all politicians have learned to use to their advantage to minimize controversy.

A few weeks later finds the changes being noticed by a few. This San Antonio Current article takes a look at the recent changes, and discussion is ripe over at Dave Farber's Interesting People mailing list (explore the thread index to see multiple and opposing opinions).

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 23 additional comments
#1 Eversurf on 31 Dec 2003 - 03:08
Like the LCD weren't expensive enough
(2 replies) #2 SanGreal on 31 Dec 2003 - 03:18
Aren't Government agencies supposed to be non-profit?
#2.1 xRKx on 31 Dec 2003 - 06:48
That doesn't preclude them from owning patents.
#2.2 SanGreal on 31 Dec 2003 - 10:17
But what benefit is there to enforcing them?
(3 replies) #3 no-sweat on 31 Dec 2003 - 04:48
stupid french..
#3.1 plasticparadox on 31 Dec 2003 - 12:00
Nothing wrong with the French.
#3.2 Eversurf on 31 Dec 2003 - 12:41
I am french......canadian
#3.3 Avicus on 31 Dec 2003 - 15:35
so sorry
lol
(1 reply) #4 frankchn on 31 Dec 2003 - 06:58
i can't seem to understand what a "government agency for atomic energy" has to do with LCD panels
#4.1 clonk on 31 Dec 2003 - 08:26
They have nothing to do with LCD's themselves, its what makes an LCD an LCD. They are concerned about "two patents for technology involved in the design and manufacture of liquid crystal modules." Although you or I may see no application beyond a pretty screen, liquid crystals obviously have uses.
(1 reply) #5 DarkCircuit on 31 Dec 2003 - 07:40
Why does everything have to be about the Chinaman?
Cant we all just get along?
#5.1 TranceSphere on 31 Dec 2003 - 11:39
Cant we all just get a bong???
#6 Arcticflare on 31 Dec 2003 - 14:30
Well, prices for LCD's may go up just a hair, maybe not even noticably so for most. And that would only be because of a supply vs. demand problem caused by one company not being able to export their screens for a while. I'm really not phased by this at all. After all, LCD's went from about 750-950 bucks to 250-350 dollars (for a 15 inch) in a really short period of time. Prices would go down a bit further if somebody would just come up with a freaking industry standard on parts for these things anyways.
(4 replies) #7 naap51stang on 31 Dec 2003 - 15:17
LOL, we bombed the wrong country. I think we need to invade France, and get them back on the right track. Those people over there are completely clueless!
Ok, they let the Germans run all over them in WW1, so they build this stupid wall between their border with Germany. So what do the Germans do in WW2? LOL, they go through Holland and come in from the north. Those socialist in that country once again prove that socialism would work, it just hasn't been tried by the right people yet. Buzzzzzzz.......it can't and never will work. When you stifel freedom, and choice, your country will die! USSR, Cuba, France etc. Just look at those for an example.

#7.1 puredeath on 31 Dec 2003 - 16:12
Another typical AmeriKKKan response… Or did you forget? I can generalize too: America is a country with no culture, ethics, or dignity. Americans are characteristically narcissistic, self-absorbed, and conceited. How’s that?

I just don't see what WW2 has to do with LCDs, unless of course Nazi Germany invented liquid crystals, amongst other things (missiles?). Being an American doesn't give you the right to insult other countries; after all, America is the only country where democracy conquered freedom.
#7.2 SanGreal on 31 Dec 2003 - 21:49
QUOTE (#7.1)
Another typical AmeriKKKan response… Or did you forget? I can generalize too: America is a country with no culture, ethics, or dignity. Americans are characteristically narcissistic, self-absorbed, and conceited. How’s that?

You sir, are an idiot. First you say we have "no culture", then you proceed to list of what you allege are cultural traits of Americans. Then you proceed to call us "narcissistic, self-absorbed, and conceited", which all mean the exact same thing. I pity those of you who don't love their country above all others.
#7.3 Arcticflare on 01 Jan 2004 - 00:57
Okay you guys, you're both wrong. First of all, intense national pride started the first world war and also the 2nd world war. You might be a little nicer if you learned your history.

It's not the greatest thing to purposefully insult another person. Now telling the truth is a different matter, even if it can be taken as an insult. However I don't see any truth here, from naap51stang, puredeath, or SanGreal. In fact I'm thoroughly embarassed by two likely juveniles who happen to be setting a bad example of my fellow americans, and also really disgusted at puredeath for having the stereotypical "bash the United States" attitude.

In truth, I'm as sick of people bringing up world war two as the rest of the world. I'm also sick of people insulting eachother's countries when they could be targeting the real problem which is the governmental figures that make the choices people are dissagreeing with so passionately.
#7.4 SanGreal on 01 Jan 2004 - 01:23
QUOTE (#7.3)
You might be a little nicer if you learned your history.

You might be less of an asshole if you learned how to read.

I stated three facts in my post. The first two relating to the definition of four words and the last being my opinion on nationalism which is infact, my opinion on nationalism. That being said, please point to the part that makes me a juvenile liar.

Thanks

P.S WWI was caused by twisted alliances, poor communication and an assassination.
(4 replies) #8 BigBoy on 31 Dec 2003 - 17:36
"America is a country with no culture"...

Haha, that's funny.

You know - I am not American myself but - I still can not say that, not even close. American culture is spreading like no other. If you don't beleive me, just check how many Coca-Cola machines you can count anywhere you live, or where the most movies played in the movie theatres are made.

But anyway - I agree - generalization is a bad thing.
#8.1 puredeath on 31 Dec 2003 - 18:46
I'm not talking about corporate influence (aka marketing). You should travel to New York; each community is like a different animal, caged from one another, in fear of an outbreak. Hence you have your China town and your Little Italy as well, amongst numerous others (Harlem?). Perhaps I’m talking about cultural integration. My job requires a lot of travel, and no matter where I’ve been, even in France, I felt welcomed (even at home, in some countries). People didn’t segregate themselves into communities, they didn’t feel the need to be special, or be different. People in America have a superiority complex, they are very material. “I’m better than the next guy, and I live in the best neighborhood, my community is upper class, and this is the most evolved state, America is #1” type of an attitude. And if you somehow don’t match their criteria for an “equal”, you are treated like a 2nd class citizen. Typical responses that I’ve got: “Oh, you’re from Germany, are you? You like America? You know, we kicked your asses in WW2… You see how French are paying us back for saving their asses? And don’t get me started about those Russkies!” At least most of them know their history. Typical, I don’t care about the rest of the world approach. And most of them don’t, result: “Bush”. Never have I felt more unwelcomed than I am in America. Sorry, but that’s the truth. It seems like French don’t have a problem with arrogance, it’s an American epidemic.
#8.2 no-sweat on 31 Dec 2003 - 20:05
QUOTE (#8.1)
It seems like French don’t have a problem with arrogance, it’s an American epidemic.

try being an american and going to france, arrogance wouldnt even begin to describe the french
#8.3 BigBoy on 31 Dec 2003 - 21:16
puredeath,

Well - good for you, if you felt wellcome everywhere but in US, I guess. I can tell you from personal experience - that varies QUITE a bit based on where you are from.

As a person that came from ex-Yugoslavia, I can tell you that I have felt VERY unwelcome in Germany, Switzerland and some other "west" European countries, and was literally blown away by how nobody cared here in US. I live in US now.

So - I beg to differ with what you said.

The truth is - there is probably plenty of it on both sides, and it just changes depending on the area. But I don't think it was invented in US.
#8.4 SanGreal on 31 Dec 2003 - 21:57
QUOTE (#8.1)
You should travel to New York; each community is like a different animal, caged from one another, in fear of an outbreak. Hence you have your China town and your Little Italy as well, amongst numerous others (Harlem?).

Every country has seperate immigrant communities. Even your beloved France and Germany have Chinatowns. If thats your definition of "no culture", I guess the whole world has no culture

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)