main
Report a problem

Neowin Review: Maxtor DiamondMax 10 250GB Hard Drive

Toxicfume   on 28 March 2005 - 15:49 · 33 comments & 7453 views

Advertisement (Why?)
After our very own Tom Graham reviewed some portable hard drives, today we'll have a look at a Desktop counterpart by Maxtor. The massive 250GB DiamondMax 10. As large hard drives are becoming of an increased importance, we will also cover a small guide so you know what to look for when buying a new hard drive.
    After plugging everything in, the drive was visible to my onboard Promise RAID/SATA Interface controller’s BIOS. In here, you can setup the “bootability” of drives and decide whether you want your hard drives to work in a RAID environment or simply to work alone; I decided to skip the RAID options and work alone. Maxtor offer a setup of tools to help you format the drive; MaxBlast, a piece of hard drive management software for Windows by Maxtor, for Maxtor drives.

    The first thing you may notice, or not, is the noise level of the hard drive while in operation – it is, to say the least, very quiet. I found noise only noticeable whilst doing sustained file transfers between itself and my DiamondMax 9. I felt the drive was probably about twice as quiet as the DiamondMax 9; serious credit to Maxtor’s “Quiet Drive” technology, the Fluid Dynamic Bearings, and the fact that the spindle runs at 7,200 RPM (Western Digital has a line of hard drives running at a noisy 10K RPM).

Will this massive drive keep up to par with the other drives available? Namely the 10K RPM Western Digital Raptor drives? On to the review...

View: Neowin's Maxtor DiamondMax 10 - 250GB Review

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 33 additional comments
(1 reply) #1 on 01 Jan 1970 - 00:00
#1.1 vetToxicfume on 28 Mar 2005 - 17:52
That's exactly the point no one seems to get here. It depends heavily on the kind of usage the drive goes through and the environment the drive is in. Personally, Seagates have given me some of the worst experiences of any hard drives, whereas they've been awesome for Tom, as he mentions in his previous reviews.

I've been using Maxtors for a long while, and I find no problems with them. It's just like how Steam works well on some people's computers and doesn't work well for others. What's so hard to comprehend here? And aside, where I live atleast, Maxtor has the great warranty options.
(1 reply) #2 on 01 Jan 1970 - 00:00
#2.1 vetToxicfume on 28 Mar 2005 - 18:09
Ofcourse, and I fully agree with you. I wouldn't forgive a system admin of a small network of computers running databases to go for quietness over performance.

And you can clearly see in my conclusion that these Maxtor drives definitely cannot compete in performance with the WD raptors. The raptors win hands down. But then you don't get those 10K RPM drives with such huge capacities, there's always a trade off - that's a no brainer. But you also need to realize for a lot of people, aesthetics are as important as performance is to you, some people don't want noise, some people don't care. It's up to you - The WD Raptors are smaller and faster but louder, the Maxtors are larger and quieter, but not as fast, and I make no attempt to try to hide that fact.

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)