apple
Report a problem

iPhone developer sues Coors for $12.5M

Tom Warren   on 16 October 2008 - 00:00 · 28 comments & 9539 views

Advertisement (Why?)
Hottrix, a small company that developed the iBeer application for iPhone and iPod Touch devices is suing Coors for $12.5M.

The claim, in a 12 page filing, is that rival application iPint is violating a copyright that the iBeer author Steve Sheraton registered.

Both applications display a virtual pint which when the device is tipped to one side mimics a real pint of lager being consumed.

Sheraton stresses that the iBeer technique was "wholly original ... and is copyrightable subject matter." Sheraton then complained to Apple, which eventually removed iPint from the App Store in the United States. However, iPint still appears in the App Store in other countries.

"We are confident that we’ve handled this matter appropriately, and will vigorously defend the action," Coors said in a statement.

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 28 additional comments
#1 Chonson on 16 Oct 2008 - 00:08
There's a whole bunch of pointless duped apps on there. When the app store first opened, there were about 5-10 flashlight apps and only one of them was decent!

The little guy is only going after the big guy in this case because they know theres a good chance of getting money out of it.
#2 Albert on 16 Oct 2008 - 00:23
geez. stupid developers fighting over a useless software idea, which are used by people with questionable tastes ...

how pointless can this be?

this sounds exactly like the kind of news some crappy sites would report in april ...
#3 lylesback2 on 16 Oct 2008 - 00:26
People will sue for any amounts of money these days, to hopefully get maybe half in an out of court settlement.
#4 Snakehn on 16 Oct 2008 - 00:38
all that drama over 2 stupid useless apps.
(4 replies) #5 vetneufuse on 16 Oct 2008 - 00:49
iSue - my new app for the iPhone... with just one finger you can sue who ever you want, it will file the application, pull fees for it out of your bank account and notify the defendant of the pending suit all with one press
#5.1 Clueless Fox on 16 Oct 2008 - 01:26
woah woah, back it up buddy. i'm already working on an app called 'iScrew' that does exactly what you just said. my lawyers will be contacting you soon enough
#5.2 Chonson on 16 Oct 2008 - 05:37
If iScrew is anything like iSue, I'm very interested.
#5.3 +TCLN Ryster on 16 Oct 2008 - 09:09
I lol'd really hard at this comment thread!
#5.4 shakey_snake on 16 Oct 2008 - 16:08
I'm right now in the process of writing iDivorce
#6 Glassed Silver on 16 Oct 2008 - 00:58
oh come on!
that is outright ridiculous...

Glassed Silver:win
#7 Don Matteo on 16 Oct 2008 - 01:32
He would never make 12k let alone 12 million. Stupid.
#8 m-p{3} on 16 Oct 2008 - 02:05
I hope common sense will prevail in this case.
#9 +techbeck on 16 Oct 2008 - 03:12
Uhhhh, hell...id sue for a life time supply of beer...not 12 mil...haha...but seriously...this is something really dumb to sue about when there are a lot of other stuff to worry about.
(2 replies) #10 +warwagon on 16 Oct 2008 - 03:28
Whats even more sad is that they could come up with a 12 page document about the law suite.
#10.1 +vlsi0n on 16 Oct 2008 - 04:34
I'm guessing there is a lot of fluff.
#10.2 SirEvan on 16 Oct 2008 - 15:31
vlsi0n said,
I'm guessing there is a lot of fluff.


quadruple spaced perhaps.....and really...really big type.
#11 roadwarrior on 16 Oct 2008 - 04:48
Shouldn't this be a patent instead of a copyright anyway? You can't copyright an idea or technique, but you can patent them. If Coors isn't using any of his images or code, then the suit should fail without question.
#12 theyarecomingforyou on 16 Oct 2008 - 04:53
So they both use a motion sensor to depict a drink being consumed? And now one wishes to sue the other because they came up with it first? Ludicrous. You shouldn't be able to protect generic ideas, let alone sue for millions of dollars.
#13 +.Vamp on 16 Oct 2008 - 08:15
They're just ****ed because iPint is free, and so much better.
iBeer costs about 89p I think, and isnt a smooth animation, its laggy. iPint is free, completely smooth and fluid, and has a fun minigame built in.
#14 njlouch on 16 Oct 2008 - 09:25
Boo ****ing hoo!
#15 MightyJordan on 16 Oct 2008 - 10:06
Two words: greedy bastards.
#16 NeoNGx on 16 Oct 2008 - 12:38
ok
#17 Magallanes on 16 Oct 2008 - 14:04
The claim, in a 12 page filing, is that rival application iPint is violating a copyright that the iBeer author Steve Sheraton registered.


AFAIK it is a patent matters and not a copyright infringement.
#18 C_Guy on 16 Oct 2008 - 14:26
Or, as an alternative to suing over pointless crap, you could just... I dunno... get a JOB.

Waiting for someone to rip off your completely lame iPhone "app", and then suing is not a job, it's a giant waste of everyone's time.
#19 Sevan on 16 Oct 2008 - 16:40
I don't know whether to laugh or frown on this one.

*sigh* Idiots.
#20 clotz2000 on 16 Oct 2008 - 18:21
This is a pointless app and definitely just an attempt to try and make a quick buck. If I were the judge I would laugh at both of them in their faces while in court and dismiss the whole thing, good thing here in the US we can waste everyone's legal time for nothing.
#21 GEIST on 16 Oct 2008 - 18:50
How insanely ridiculous. They should sit down and settle this over a real pint of beer.
#22 lfLASHlNZl on 16 Oct 2008 - 20:38
when the iphone can produce a REAL Bear, then i be interested!

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)