Supergirl (TV Series)

By Rappy
in The Media Room

 Share

Recommended Posts

Grand Master

Son_Of_Dad

Posted
Posted

Sometimes they make good choices. Laurence Fishburne for one as Perry White. Now he's a great actor. But doing it just for the sake of diversity is ridiculous. It's the social justice mentality through and through.


You make an all white / all hetero cast today you'll have 50 nut jobs protesting very loudly before the first episode has aired.

Grand Master

Jase

Posted
Posted

Ugh.. This show man...I just can't put my finger on it... Maybe I need a giant button titled "cringe" so when I press it I won't need to cringe as much while viewing this horrible gob***** of a cheesefest.

The CGI is poor, the acting is poor, the characters chosen for example, Jimmy is outright laughable, I'm not talking about his skin colour here.. jimmy is supposed to be dorky, fun type of guy.. And yet they give us a supermodel z grade actor who looks as stiff as an erected board.. Sure he is built well but When you think Jimmy Olsen and he's from an African American decent with a dorky fun shtick, I instantly thought of Donald Glover.

The airbrushed makeup on most of the actors is overthe****ingly done.

The action scenes are also bad and the super speed is over used.

There is nothing Super about this show.

I'm not even sure it will make it to season 2

Veteran

greenwizard88

Posted
Posted

The episode 2 trailer already feels methodical. I'll probably watch the next few episodes, but I'm not feeling optimistic.

Actually, let me tell you how this show is going to pan out: It will suck for the first season, the second season will have some high highs and more low lows, and a strong dose of mediocracy. The 3rd season will be when the show starts to find its stride, but by that point the ratings will have suffered too much and the show will get canceled. The 3rd season will end in a cliffhanger, and never concluded.

The alternative is that Supergirl has some hook not yet reveled in the pilot episode that makes me reconsider my opinion and the show lasts 7+ seasons. That'd be cool, but I'm not going to hold my breath.

Grand Master

Scorbing

Posted
Posted

I really had high hopes for this show since its by the same people that do the Flash and Arrow. I'm thinking CBS may have something to do with the way the story is told, because these guys do great with their shows on CW

Well here's the problem that I see:

The acting on the part of some of the show's actors is terrible. Some of them act like they don't want to be there. The show seems to be directed towards young teens and kids and that's a mistake. They need to balance it. Make it a bit more serious and dark like Agents of Shield is. The whole Jimmy Olsen I'm-in-love-with-supergirl BS has got to stop. The love triangle crap needs to go away. This ain't Days of Our Lives. People want to see action and Supergirl, not two idiots fighting over her love and acting stupid. I saw the second episode last night online and I was less than thrilled with it. The most interesting part of the episode was the government dude when his eyes turned red. Wasn't expecting that one. Other than that, the episode sucked.

Grand Master

seeprime

Posted
Posted (edited)

My 2 cents: I waited until Flash was on Netflix to binge watch it. So, I watch Supergirl and Flash within 24 hours of each other. Supergirl began with a weak Krypton origin scene, The rest of the episode was just okay, not compelling enough to want to make me want to see more ASAP. It did have some humor and good effects. Flash, on the other hand, had an excellent background story in the pilot and was strong through the whole episode, with excellent effects and humor in the right places. I'll try Supergirl again when I can see it commercial free (I don't use a DVR, yet) as commercials ruin any action show simply by removing the story and putting you into five minutes of stupid distractions. 

I do like the casting of a former Superman (Smallville) and the original Supergirl (1984 movie)as her parents in the new show. I also like that Barry Allen's dad was the original Flash (1990 TV series). Very cool to see this.

Grand Master

DocM

Posted
Posted

I really had high hopes for this show since its by the same people that do the Flash and Arrow. I'm thinking CBS may have something to do with the way the story is told, because these guys do great with their shows on CW

 

News flash: the percentage of drop from it's prmiere, considering its time change and loss of the BBT lead in, is considered below average. It's also tied for #1 scripted with Blindspot for the night.

We won't know for a few weeks.

Grand Master

Scorbing

Posted
Posted (edited)

I predict they will ax it sooner than later:

http://deadline.com/2015/11/supergirl-ratings-fall-monday-night-football-chargers-bears-blindspot-nbc-1201617191/

Now...Don't get me wrong...I would love for this show to be successful. I kinda like the chic. She's cute and she's not doing a bad job, but this show should be in Syndication not CBS. It has a better chance to make it on the Sci-Fi channel or USA Network than it does on CBS. If it gets cancelled (which looks inevitable the way the ratings are going), I hope Sci-Fi, CW or USA grabs it.

 

Edited by Scorbing
Rookie

aolish

Posted
Posted

I saw the 3rd episode to Supergirl and I have to say that this episode was far better than the pilot episode that came out. The biggest problem I found with the pilot episode is it felt way to rushed. I feel that episode could of easily been a 2 part series, instead it was all crammed up into one episode. I felt that the third episode was a lot better, it didn't feel no where near as rushed as the pilot and the action sequences were simply fantastic considering this was a TV budget show. In addition the end of the third episode had me wanting more. Great overall episode and I hope to see it continue this trend later on. If anyone only seen the Pilot episode I strongly recommend watching the 2nd and 3rd episodes as its in my opinion much better than the Pilot.

  • +Anarkii and Scorbing
  • Like 2
Grand Master

Scorbing

Posted
Posted

I saw the 3rd episode to Supergirl and I have to say that this episode was far better than the pilot episode that came out. The biggest problem I found with the pilot episode is it felt way to rushed. I feel that episode could of easily been a 2 part series, instead it was all crammed up into one episode. I felt that the third episode was a lot better, it didn't feel no where near as rushed as the pilot and the action sequences were simply fantastic considering this was a TV budget show. In addition the end of the third episode had me wanting more. Great overall episode and I hope to see it continue this trend later on. If anyone only seen the Pilot episode I strongly recommend watching the 2nd and 3rd episodes as its in my opinion much better than the Pilot.

The stupid love triangle drama between the stupid Jimmy Olsen and the other idiot is really getting on my nerves. It's really unnecessary. The guy playing Jimmy Olsen needs acting classes. The other guy is just plain boring and is not far from winning a lousy actor award either. They really need to make some changes to this show if they want it to succeed and they need to make them soon before its too late.

Grand Master

DocM

Posted
Posted

 

" I predict they will ax it sooner than later:

http://deadline.com/2015/11/supergirl-ratings-fall-monday-night-football-chargers-bears-blindspot-nbc-1201617191/ "

That quotes a 1.7/5,  but the later live + same day streams shows 2.2/8.8 and it being the #15 show with the key 18-54 demographic. The live + 3 day streams should be more indicative.

TOP PRIMETIME PROGRAMS
(Nov. 2-8, 2015; live plus same-day)

Adults 18-49 rating
1.  Sunday Night Football: Philadelphia-Dallas (NBC), 8.4
2.  The Walking Dead (AMC), 6.2
3.  Empire (Fox), 4.6
3.  Monday Night Football: Indianapolis-Carolina (ESPN), 4.6
5.  CMA Awards (ABC), 3.8
6.  The Big Bang Theory (CBS), 3.7
7.  College football: LSU-Alabama (CBS), 3.6
8.  The Voice-Monday (NBC), 3.3
10.  Thursday Night Football: Cleveland-Cincinnati (NFLN), 3.1
11.  60 Minutes (CBS), 2.7
12.  Talking Dead (AMC), 2.5
13.  NCIS (CBS), 2.3
13.  Grey’s Anatomy (ABC), 2.3
15.  Supergirl (CBS), 2.2
15.  Scandal (ABC), 2.2
15.  Blindspot (NBC), 2.2
18.  Survivor (CBS), 2.0
18.  The Voice-Tuesday (NBC), 2.0
20.  NCIS: New Orleans (CBS), 1.9
20.  Dancing With the Stars (ABC), 1.9
20.  Scorpion (CBS), 1.9
20.  Life in Pieces (CBS), 1.9
20.  How to Get Away With Murder (ABC), 1.9

  • Scorbing and President Devil
  • Like 2
Grand Master

Scorbing

Posted
Posted

 

" I predict they will ax it sooner than later:

http://deadline.com/2015/11/supergirl-ratings-fall-monday-night-football-chargers-bears-blindspot-nbc-1201617191/ "

That quotes a 1.7/5,  but the later live + same day streams shows 2.2/8.8 and it being the #15 show with the key 18-54 demographic. The live + 3 day streams should be more indicative.

TOP PRIMETIME PROGRAMS
(Nov. 2-8, 2015; live plus same-day)

Adults 18-49 rating
1.  Sunday Night Football: Philadelphia-Dallas (NBC), 8.4
2.  The Walking Dead (AMC), 6.2
3.  Empire (Fox), 4.6
3.  Monday Night Football: Indianapolis-Carolina (ESPN), 4.6
5.  CMA Awards (ABC), 3.8
6.  The Big Bang Theory (CBS), 3.7
7.  College football: LSU-Alabama (CBS), 3.6
8.  The Voice-Monday (NBC), 3.3
10.  Thursday Night Football: Cleveland-Cincinnati (NFLN), 3.1
11.  60 Minutes (CBS), 2.7
12.  Talking Dead (AMC), 2.5
13.  NCIS (CBS), 2.3
13.  Grey’s Anatomy (ABC), 2.3
15.  Supergirl (CBS), 2.2
15.  Scandal (ABC), 2.2
15.  Blindspot (NBC), 2.2
18.  Survivor (CBS), 2.0
18.  The Voice-Tuesday (NBC), 2.0
20.  NCIS: New Orleans (CBS), 1.9
20.  Dancing With the Stars (ABC), 1.9
20.  Scorpion (CBS), 1.9
20.  Life in Pieces (CBS), 1.9
20.  How to Get Away With Murder (ABC), 1.9

It's a shame that it's not doing so well because, for a TV show with a limited budget, the special effects are great. I really hope they find some way to make it work.

Grand Master

Scorbing

Posted
Posted

We'll see, but I don't even pay attention to the live showing ratings anymorec because of DVR's and streaming. 

true but remember, CBS doesn't care about how many people watch the show on their website (streaming). All they care about is Live viewing. If not enough people are watching it when they air the episodes, they will tank it, no matter how many people watch it online.

 

Grand Master

Son_Of_Dad

Posted
Posted

the Supergirl Pilot cost CBS $14 million


Is that high these days? I remember the Star Trek Voyager pilot costing 6 million and that was 20 years ago. At the time I think Babylon 5 creator/EP said he could produce 1.5 seasons for the same amount.

On the subject of money they need to pump more into FX, when she flew out and around the buildings at the end of the episode it looked horribly unrealistic.

  • President Devil and Scorbing
  • Like 2
Grand Master

Scorbing

Posted
Posted

Is that high these days? I remember the Star Trek Voyager pilot costing 6 million and that was 20 years ago. At the time I think Babylon 5 creator/EP said he could produce 1.5 seasons for the same amount.

On the subject of money they need to pump more into FX, when she flew out and around the buildings at the end of the episode it looked horribly unrealistic.

The visual effects are not bad for a TV show. Hell, they are way better than the 90s Superman with Dean Cane, but I think more than anything, they need to change the way the story line is going. The stupid love triangle needs to go. The guy playing Jimmy Olsen sucks. The other idiotic guy "in love" with her needs to get acting lessons and stop being so stupid. The show needs to be a bit more dark and serious like Agents of Shield, otherwise it will fail. The way it's going, I don't even think a Superman cameo by Henry Cavill will save it from cancellation. They need to act and they need to act quick before CBS pulls the plug.

Grand Master

+Anarkii Subscriber²

Posted
  • Subscriber²
Posted

The visual effects are not bad for a TV show. Hell, they are way better than the 90s Superman with Dean Cane, but I think more than anything, they need to change the way the story line is going. The stupid love triangle needs to go. The guy playing Jimmy Olsen sucks. The other idiotic guy "in love" with her needs to get acting lessons and stop being so stupid. The show needs to be a bit more dark and serious like Agents of Shield, otherwise it will fail. The way it's going, I don't even think a Superman cameo by Henry Cavill will save it from cancellation. They need to act and they need to act quick before CBS pulls the plug.


I somewhat agree with you. While the 3rd episode did pick up the pace from the slow 2nd one, I have a feeling now that Kara is out to prove herself and stand alone, I reckon she may just do that. If the show makes it to a season ender, lets hope Henry Cavill (if he actually makes a appearance) would be great as a season ender where Supergirl has to save her cousin in some way. What she needs is a villian that is a friend of hers, then turns and comes back next season, like that guy who is in love with her. Think Ford in Agents of Shield. 

Once a proper storyline or plot has been established I think Supergirl would be great, much like Arrow, Flash and even Gotham. 

Grand Master

DocM

Posted
Posted

true but remember, CBS doesn't care about how many people watch the show on their website (streaming). All they care about is Live viewing. If not enough people are watching it when they air the episodes, they will tank it, no matter how many people watch it online.

 

Not so as paradigms are changing and lines are blurring.  Their streaming service has ads as well, sometimes more, and they get paid for them. Ditto "regular" HULU unless you pay exra to remove them. As such, those live + numbers matter to the bottom line.

Grand Master

ThisSiteHasLostItsCharm

Posted
Posted

 

" I predict they will ax it sooner than later:

http://deadline.com/2015/11/supergirl-ratings-fall-monday-night-football-chargers-bears-blindspot-nbc-1201617191/ "

That quotes a 1.7/5,  but the later live + same day streams shows 2.2/8.8 and it being the #15 show with the key 18-54 demographic. The live + 3 day streams should be more indicative.

TOP PRIMETIME PROGRAMS
(Nov. 2-8, 2015; live plus same-day)

Adults 18-49 rating
1.  Sunday Night Football: Philadelphia-Dallas (NBC), 8.4
2.  The Walking Dead (AMC), 6.2
3.  Empire (Fox), 4.6
3.  Monday Night Football: Indianapolis-Carolina (ESPN), 4.6
5.  CMA Awards (ABC), 3.8
6.  The Big Bang Theory (CBS), 3.7
7.  College football: LSU-Alabama (CBS), 3.6
8.  The Voice-Monday (NBC), 3.3
10.  Thursday Night Football: Cleveland-Cincinnati (NFLN), 3.1
11.  60 Minutes (CBS), 2.7
12.  Talking Dead (AMC), 2.5
13.  NCIS (CBS), 2.3
13.  Grey’s Anatomy (ABC), 2.3
15.  Supergirl (CBS), 2.2
15.  Scandal (ABC), 2.2
15.  Blindspot (NBC), 2.2
18.  Survivor (CBS), 2.0
18.  The Voice-Tuesday (NBC), 2.0
20.  NCIS: New Orleans (CBS), 1.9
20.  Dancing With the Stars (ABC), 1.9
20.  Scorpion (CBS), 1.9
20.  Life in Pieces (CBS), 1.9
20.  How to Get Away With Murder (ABC), 1.9

sport and walkinh dead at the top, that's just wrong....

twd is ok but certainly not awesome, neither is football, in fact i find football boring..rather watch rugby.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing